Lol, this entire thread reminds me of why I’m indecisive about trading my 330i Saloon, when what I really want is a fun estate (read RS4)
I only do 2500pa so Petrol/diesel economy is neither here nor there. The Beemer (its an ’52 plate) has had all the wear & tear bits done. But most poignently:
a)Its the semi auto, and on the odd work journey is excelently comfortable, smooth and acceptably economical on m/way with cruise (32mpg)
b)Thats ^^ with a bike carrier on the roof. A recent journey to Afan with all my gear and 1 bike on the roof averaged 28.5 from start to finish (M25 / A40 / M52 / twisty roads to Cwn Carn then to Cymmer)
c)I can get all the camping / bike gear for two bikes on the roof and still have room for 2 passengers – I’ve done that to CYB.
d) It can be a hoot in sports mode with the T/C off if you want it to be.
As much as I’d like an RS4 or acceptably performing diesel, in my circumstances the minute I have to borrow more than £100 to get a similar car in estate form it just isn’t economically viable.