Its about to get cold according to Metcheck, so go on then, recommend me some winter gloves. I've had 2 pairs of Endura Strikes which fit just lovely, but the liner has come undone in the wash so I can't get them on. AND the waterproof membrane idea is plain daft – you end up with dry hands surrounded by blocks of ice.
I like the look of the Spesh Sub Zero gloves with seperate liner and outer shell – are they any good?
What else is good?

spesh gloves are the best cold weather gloves i have tried but you need to take care with the outer gloves liner as it eventually comes out if you remove your hand while still wearing the inner- does that make sense?

they are warm tho, I suffer with really cold fingers during winter night rides and last winter these gloves were good even during the snow and ice.

661 winter storms…………. nuff said

Well not really, like any winter gloves every downside is you miss the true feel and connection with your bike. Still, warm gloves and 2 winters old now

The Gore Alp x waterproof, are pretty bad, bought them last year, very dissapointed. Going to have to buy new gloves this winter – again!

Noticed some nice new dakine storm (I think)gortex gloves the other day. I have some sealskinz, but only use them if the temprature slips below -20 c as they are to thick and warm. Tried the dakine ones on much thinner and comfortable, I'll probabbly get a pair this winter. £55 mind…..

Used Specialized sub zeros last winter commuting and they are a great glove(s). One of the best things about them is their adaptability. In the really cold mornings you might need the outer and inner but only the inner for the ride home. I also bought some merino glove liners and this set up was perfect. No cold hands at all and rode in temperatures down to -10, ice forming on the bike, ice on my eyebrows, etc but my hands were still warm. Only issue I have is that they're not waterproof so thinking of buying some Tuff Bag mits this year for really wet commutes.

Tried 661 storms – not breathable at all, cuff too short, inner comes out when you take them off, not waterproof, but they are warm.

Same problem with 661, cuff too which means my hand get's cold when it's really baltic.

I use some snowboarding gloves which seem to be working fine.

Spesh Radiant here, superb gloves.

second the radiants, but too warm for anything above freezing..! Otherwise Specialized Deflects are fine down to zero-ish.

For everything but extremely cold weather (and rain too I guess) Gore windstopper gloves are great, you can also buy undergloves for when it's really cold.

I prefer Windstopper gloves too. Can't get on with chunky waterproof jobbers.

I have to say my Endura Strikes are not great – same as OP, the liner will not stay put in them at all. In wet weather they work well, only a wee dribble on two fingers…(!) Not sure many gloves would be great though. I am finding myself using my extremeties base layer gloves and extremeties windstopper gloves more…

You've just missed the Aldi winter cycling gloves – not the most breathable but worked a treat throughout the unexpectedly cold and snowy conditions last winter – not bad for a fiver or whatever they were!

Lidl have winter gloves in stores tomorrow.

I've got some Spesh Sub-Zeros. It rarely gets cold enough to wear them,they are warm. Had them for seven years now and they're as good as ever. Never washed 'em thogh..

sealskins gloves seem to be made for people with immensly small fingers… i used a set last winter, didnt hate them too much, but I've gone to try them and i dont know how on earth I'll be able to control the handlebars with them. seemed tight on me when I was a year younger, now their impossible.

I shouldnt have to buy XL, maybe XXL gloves aged 15. 🙂

Spesh Deflects, still great feel through the grips and levers, ulna nerve padding included, anything else is too warm. If it gets mega cold/wet, I consider wearing a pair of surgical gloves underneath but rarely does it get that bad

Aldi neoprene's. Superb.
And cheap.

I shall be wearing my old motorbike gloves again, I've not found a pushbike glove that actually keeps me warm once winter really arrives. The motorbike ones give precisely no feel whatsoever, but then again neither does any other glove once my fingers stop working. I've got an old pair of Specialized Subzeros which do me for commuting though since it's only 3 miles.

I used these for approx 4yrs along with a merino liner but they are dropping to pieces now:

http://www.bonthronebikes.co.uk/899-230119

0091paddy- those are roadie gloves?

Think I will try something like Spesh (Radiant etc) next partly due to their rep for getting most of the basics throughout their range right I guess.

Edit: Ah, bikeradar review not good for feel.

Thanks for the heads up on Deflects (http://www.bikeradar.com/gear/category/clothing/gloves/product/deflect-09-10668)

Gore bikewear Mistral III 🙂

Hi Mr P.. it's Matt, how you doing?

Cannondale le carbon ftw.

http://www.bikeradar.com/gear/category/clothing/gloves/product/le-gloves-10738

Depends on how cold your hands get. 661 storms never kept me warm (and this is only down to about -3C). Now use the thickest sealskin ones, much better. Still use a merino liner if really cold, but was toasty on the SPAM winter challenge that was about -10C at times. Most people would find this too hot but it's great for me.