Viewing 10 posts - 1 through 10 (of 10 total)
  • is there any point …1 x 10 question
  • tymbian
    Free Member

    I’m currently running 1 x 9 with an 11/ 34 cassette. Is there any point going to 1 x 10 with a 11/ 36 or should I just get a 11/36 9 speed cassette?

    njee20
    Free Member

    They don’t make 11-36 9 speed cassettes, only a Deore 12-36.

    nick1962
    Free Member

    If you really,really do need an 11 -36 you can always replace the 12t and use your 11 t sprocket from your current 11-34 instead.

    Northwind
    Full Member

    Yeah, but the deore-spec 12-36 is as heavy as a planet. Sure I’ve got one somewhere if anyone wants it, they can have it for the price of postage, which will be one million pounds.

    Junkyard
    Free Member

    He is not wrong – get a 22 front and you even save weight and cheaper than chaing all your drive train
    17.83 [ 22 32 and 9 speed] gear inches* v 17.29 gear inches[ 10 speed and 24 36]

    I guess if you really want to then you could but for me it is costly change for only very marginal gains

    * 16.78 gear inches if you do 22 34 which is available in lighter than Deore @ 9 speed

    tymbian
    Free Member

    @ junkyard..I take it the 17.83 gear inches you mentioned are for a 2 x 9 set-up ( 22 32 rings ). I don’t have the lugs on my crank or Renthal chainring for a 2 x set-up. I’ve currently a 32 ring and a Sram pg990 with 11 34 ( I think ) cassette. I was thinking of changing to a 34 front and a whatever 36 rear. Do you know what my options are re. cassette?

    njee20
    Free Member

    Whilst there’s virtually nothing in it 32-34 is a marginally easier gear than 34-36. So going 1×10 will cost you a teeny bit of bottom end.

    Junkyard
    Free Member

    @ junkyard..I take it the 17.83 gear inches you mentioned are for a 2 x 9 set-up ( 22 32 rings ).

    Yes

    I don’t have the lugs on my crank or Renthal chainring for a 2 x set-up.

    AH

    I’ve currently a 32 ring and a Sram pg990 with 11 34 ( I think ) cassette.

    24.56 gear inches

    I was thinking of changing to a 34 front and a whatever 36 rear.

    24.65 gear inches

    You will not notice any difference IMHO

    Do you know what my options are re. cassette?

    No I am 9 speed. I would just stick with it personally and run a 34 if you want.The lighter stuff Sram and Xt XTR comes in 11-34 [ and probably 12-34]
    You need a new shifter, chain ,rings and mech to gain basically the same range with 10 clicks instead of 9
    80.67 gear inches 34-11 [ 10 speeed]
    75.93 gear inches 32-11 [ 9 speed]
    I guess that is where your extra gear is ie 9-10 and not an easier first/lower gears

    tymbian
    Free Member

    Thanks, The easier first wasn’t a deal sealer for me as I don’t like to ( read can’t ( ex-smoker )) spin for too long as I always end up changing down and mashing…so might as well run a 34. I was looking to build up a bike for my son using parts he already has but he runs single-speed atm. If it was worthwhile I would have given him my 1×9 set-up and gone 1×10 myself. I might as well set his up 1×9 also..Any deals about??

    rotten
    Free Member

    Going 1×10 also means you can get a clutch type rear mech.

Viewing 10 posts - 1 through 10 (of 10 total)

The topic ‘is there any point …1 x 10 question’ is closed to new replies.