If probably take the Lyrik – but then I’m Rockshox all the way at the moment with a Pike Ultimate RC2 on the hardtail and a Lyrik RCT3 (charger 2) on the full suss. The Lyrik has seem a lot of abuse over the 4 or more years I’ve had it – been at 140 / 160 / 170 and now 150mm travel in that time. Had a solo air shaft in it to start with and since then it’s had B1 and now C1 airshafts. It started life as a Yari but then got the charger upgrade, SKF Lyrik seals and debonair air shafts.
What I like about it is how it’s been upgradable and to date everything has been backwards compatible. I’ve also managed to crash it and have some scratches in the left stanchion but that doesn’t seem to have been a problem for the fork and it’s not even taking much dirt through the seals due to the scratches.
Really user serviceable – the only thing I haven’t done is the actual charger damper itself. I’m taking the don’t fix it if it isn’t broken approach on that. I do regular lower services though and the airshafts have been changed fairly regularly so haven’t needed a seal refresh.
The Helm is always billed as very adjustable, but an Lyrik Ultimate now has a lot of adjustment with HSC / LSC / Rebound / tokens / air pressure.
Maybe the Helm is lighter as it’s more at the level of a Pike? When I bought my Pike Ultimate I considered the Helm / Pike / Selva / Fox 34 / DT Swiss forks and other then the Selva I wasn’t tempted with any of the others. If a Selva R had come in the same price as the Pike I might have gone for it just to have something a bit different but it was a few hundred quid more.
Given the Lyrik is also cheaper I’d definitely go with that I think.