Heavy flannel shirt recommendations

I’m looking for a decent Flannel shirt of the thicker variety for winter. To be worn over a base layer, so more of a shirt/light jacket hybrid. Probably wool not cotton based.  I quite like some of the Fjallraven stuff but the choice is bewildering and difficult to guage what the material is like online. So looking for suggestions. Ta muchly.

Fat Face or Burgs overshirts are the way forward. I’ve got a selection in various weights up to proper shirt jacks that feel more like jackets. They’re double cosy now it’s getting to that time of year 😀

Finisterre Beardsmore is excellent. I’ve got 3 but 2 were from Reskinned (used or returned under warranty and fixed)

They’re lovely things

Barbour have a selection

Barbour have a selection

I am wearing one now. I wear it a lot but have never thought to wear it riding.

Dickies ‘Sacramento’. Absolutely bomb proof.

Thanks 🙂

but have never thought to wear it riding.

Me neither, I don’t think anyone mentioned riding wear? Just winter outdoor casual wear. Maybe for winter walks.

Finisterre Beardsmore is excellent. I’ve got 3 but 2 were from Reskinned (used or returned under warranty and fixed)

They’re lovely things

The Beardsmore is brushed cotton and not very heavy though (I do have one and it is lovely and soft) so may not meet requirement of the OP.  I also have a Gylly shirt from Finisterre, it’s cotton again, but midweight (thicker than a normal shirt) and the fabric weave is very tight which makes it warm and windproof.

I have a few of the Alpkit ones, have one on at the moment, they seem pretty decent and hard wearing

I bought a Fox Gamut shirt cheap off SportPursuit. Lovely n warm

https://www.sportpursuit.com/catalog/product/view/id/3426514

only Small left on there, but may be able to track down elsewhere.

Dixxon shirts well worth a look.

Dakine for me

Most flannel shirts are mostly cotton – flannel is the soft weave rather than the check pattern.

I looked at the thick ‘wool’ check fjallraven shirt (“Canada” and was surprised how little wool there is in it (25%) and how rough it felt.  It might be hardwearing but it didn’t feel like it was going to be cosy.

I’ve got an old Howies padded flannel shirt I wear a lot, and a DHB one I picked up in the CRC sale that’s really comfortable.  I’d look at padded rather than just thick to get warmth for weight.

Superdry often have a good selection of padded or lined over shirts. I have one with quilted lining which has lasted me ten years or so now. Recently picked up a decent Borg/Sherpa lined one

Edit – I realise this is not strictly what the op askedb for, bit worth checking out nonetheless

Re Fjallraven, the skog is better than the Canada.

Thanks all, some great leads to check out here.

Endura do a Shacket, a lined jacket. Last year they were checked pattern, this year they are plain. I have one and use it all the time over a base layer

Me neither, I don’t think anyone mentioned riding wear? Just winter outdoor casual wear. Maybe for winter walks.

Sorry, missed that bit!

The Barbour one(s) I have are very nice, but not as warm as youngest_oab’s Rab or Dakine wintery warm shirts…

I’ve got a few cordouroy and ‘lumberjack’ overshirts from M&S.. I like them..

https://www.marksandspencer.com/search?intid=normal&langId=-24&storeId=10151&catalogId=10051&searchType=categoryTypeAhead&originalPrice=30%2C90&searchTerm=overshirt&filter=Categories%253DSC_Level_1_586

Is this any good for your?

https://www.varusteleka.com/en/product/sarma-wool-field-shirt/62384

Just make sure to get one that matches your woodburner: https://mcnairshirts.com/

I do really like the McNair stuff, but I couldn’t swing spending that much on a shirt! One day…

What’s so good about Dixxon ? Just looks like a well marketed drop ship?

Fwiw Amazon basics line do a fine line of flannels for messing about in. I pretty much live in them.  Pick them up for about a 10er. And oddly enough people do ask me where I got them.

Got a couple of fox flannels for “good”

Used to use fatface ones religiously but the quality is crap now and they shrink .

I find Portuguese Flannel make some great overshirts. They have a wool section as well as the regular cotton and cord offerings.

AW24 Wool Series

AW24 Overshirts

Fat Moose

Shirts & overshirts

If you want a wool shirt look at Swanndri bush shirts.

If you want a flannel shirt the Dickies Sacramento is nice.

Rapanui are flooding my FB feed with ads for their shirts

Pendleton are very nice but not cheap.
I use Oakley flannels for riding, they’re part of the snowboard range.

I have one of the Varusteleka shirts (albeit the red version) that ElShalimo linked above – its really nice, proper wool and made in Europe if that matters to you. I like that they make two version, regular and long, as I’m tall but skinny so could get a nice length without being baggy around the middle.

I like this from John Lewis.  Seem durable and thick.

Aubin Ravendale Wool Herringbone Shirt, Khaki £149.00

https://www.johnlewis.com/aubin-ravendale-wool-herringbone-shirt-khaki/p112240421

Aubin Lyaghts Wool Overshirt, Navy, Navy  £129.00

https://www.johnlewis.com/aubin-lyaghts-wool-overshirt-navy/navy/p5715941

@steezysix – is it easy to wash/look after?

I’m very tempted to get one myself

FWIW, Aubin tend to have very good sales after every season. My mate at work always buys their stuff when reduced.

I’m a big fan of Passenger clothing and have a few of their heavyweight shirts. Their summer stuff is a big logo heavy but winter spec clothing is right nice.

Wool shirts are very nice and warm.

I just wash them in wool cycle.

FWIW, Aubin tend to have very good sales after every season. My mate at work always buys their stuff when reduced.

Yes, I went a bit late last time and they were sold out.  I am going to get myself two of them this time. I like the pockets because they are “expandable” and easily fit my mobile.  Last time they were on sale the price was around £95.

@Elshalimo

is it easy to wash/look after?

I’m very tempted to get one myself

I haven’t washed it haven’t washed it very many times – because it’s wool, it doesn’t really hold on to smells, so generally if you just air it out it’s ok to wear multiple days/weeks without feeling dirty. Also I’m normally wearing a short or long sleeve t-shirt underneath so it doesn’t get very sweaty.

It says it’s machine washable, but the few times I’ve cleaned it I just put it in warm water with some wool detergent and do it by hand. Then roll it in a towel and compress to remove as much water as possible before hanging it to dry. If there’s any small stains I just use a wet cloth and scrub it off.

Only potential issue is that the forearms are pretty snug fitting, doesn’t bother me but some of the reviews on their site mention it. I bought mine 4+ years ago though so they might have solved that with the current ones.

Thanks

I’ve got arms like pipe cleaners so shouldn’t be an issue for me.

Uniqlo do a wide range of flannel shirts, mostly check patterns but a wide range of colours and type of check, also the weights vary a lot, from thin, almost office weight, up to really thick, snug ones that work well with something like a thick fleece or down gilet or denim jacket. I’ve got a flannel-lined Lee Storm Rider denim jacket, with a corduroy collar, that’s perfect with the Uniqlo flannel shirts I’ve got, and I’ve got a Uniqlo down gilet that’s ideal for wearing over the top. The shirts are all roughly £35-ish; I haven’t had any need to buy any for ages, I must have ten or more, ‘cos I seldom wear them through the summer.

The Americans do some things the best, Burgers, Diabetes, Petrol Stations and Flannel shirts.

Dixxon, Dakine, Carhartt (not Carhartt WIP) and Orvis all make nice Flannels.  I’d love a Pendleton but apparently they’ve been bought and quality (but not the price) has dropped.  Filson shirts are also great apparently but not tried them yet.

Can’t believe how much some of you spend on shirts. It’s making Rapha look cheap, and even Pas Normal seems quite good value in comparison.