Been trying some over the last few weeks and this is what I think.
Summary:
Whyte T129.
good: Spec. Price.
bad: Not enough travel up front. Not enough clearance on back. Can you buy one still?
Stumpy Carbon Comp.
good: Seemed the fastest.
bad: Suspension a bit remote. Non standard shock. Carbon phobia.
Tallboy Alu.
good: Can’t think of anything, but it was certainly a nice ride.
bad: For what you get for 3K it’s an upgrade opportunity waiting to happen. Their sizing is off and I was on something too small.
Salsa Horsethief.
good: Less remote suspension.
bad: For what it is (a Taiwanese frame) the frame is not cheap.
Summary of the Summary:
All are very nice and I’d be more than happy with any of them.
Just ordered a Horsethief.