For winter, I’ve ended up with a set of Five Ten guide tennies, which are clumpy but work great, and some Columbia Fairbanks omni-heats, which are warmer but not quite as sticky. Neither are riding shoes but they work better overall than any “proper” riding shoe I’ve used which is pretty damning criticism tbf.
Hopefully the trailcross gtx delivers but even then… “cutouts to let water drain from the shoe”, I mean yes I have had times when that would be good but other times your foot is just in water and that sounds suspiciously like it’s just a hole?