- Electric Piano, any advice?
I’ll lay my cards on the table. I am not musical, I can’t play any instruments whatsoever. I have no knowledge of musical instruments.Posted 4 months ago
Mrs YP would like an electric piano. We used to have an upright, but it had to go when we moved house. She has quite an ability to play, and for Christmas / Birthday / Special Day I’d like to buy her a new one that can sit on a bench (i.e. apparently she doesn’t want one on a base or stand)
I’m trying to surprise her, so am asking no questions. Research suggests either Roland, Yamaha, or Kawai as being the major makes. However I have no way of knowing of the quality of any one over another.
It won’t be cheap, but cheaper than my bike or cameras! I have a budget of about £1K.
Surely someone on here will have more than my zero knowledge, and be able to offer some suggestions.piemonsterMember
Whereabouts are you, there’s what looks like a nice condition Yamaha Aurius YDP163 going on Gumtree just outside Edinburgh for £400.Posted 4 months agoBlobOnAStickSubscriber
I have a Korg SP250 (there’s one on eBay for 500 s/h: https://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/Korg-SP250BK-88-Key-Popular-Portable-Piano-Package-Black/282945131665?hash=item41e0d81491:g:Dx0AAOSwKFpa5kwr).
When a pianist who supports a local choir had a play on it, he was miffed as he’d just bought a Yamaha P90(?) and he was disappointed as his didn’t have as many voices, but the keyboard feel was just as good as his. He said that although the Yamaha made a nice sound, it was a bit limited to sounding like a piano, whereas the Korg does a good job of sounding like a piano, organ (pipe), organ (hammond-style), strings, etc etc.
I’ve played for a few years now and the variety of voices have been a great benefit, it wasn’t something I was particularly looking for, but it’s nice to be able to play in a voice that emulates the original track (if you’re playing a cover).Posted 4 months agoBlobOnAStickSubscriberRioSubscriber
I have a Yamaha P45, but I’m just someone who wants to be able to bash out a tune with headphones on, not a proper piano player. I went to a digital piano specialist to buy it and asked the guy in the shop to demo it, and I suggest you do the same; at the time I bought it there seemed to be a degree of price fixing so there was no point in shopping around online for a discount. Some things to think about – keyboard quality (obviously) – a bit more money will get you one with wooden keys which may or may not matter, speaker quality – can it do the bass notes? (not an issue if you’re mainly using headphones), polyphony (the P45 does 64 max, better pianos do more), pedal quantity and quality – the single pedal that comes with the P45 is pretty crap, and then the minefields of voices and connectivity – the P45 has a few voices and connects to my iPad for Garageband which is enough for me but some people want bells and whistles. TL:DR, you may be entering a minefield if you’re not a piano player.Posted 4 months agoSuperficialMember
I think this sounds like a great idea – a really thoughtful gift. I would be concentrating on getting something fairly middle-of-the-road in terms of tone, though, and an agreement with the shop that it can be returned at a later date if your Mrs is dead-set on something different.
They all can sit on a table or whatever, but a stand is way better to use.
Good luck.Posted 4 months agoplumberMember
I sold my US les paul to buy a nord electro 6d 61
absolutely the right thing to do, les paul was sat in its case for years and now I can’t wait to get home to play my electro everyday. Having played every keyboard on the market I consider Nords very special if a bit niche
Neighbours might not agreePosted 4 months agoedhornbySubscriber
Nord are proper high quality gear and brilliant samples, with a price tag to match but for a home occasional player they feel like overkill. the Korg and Yamaha’s seem like good options – the main issue may be the height from the bottom of the base to the key level if it’s going on a table etc because in order to play comfortably you need a straight wrist (like typing on a PC keyboard)Posted 4 months agoMalvern RiderMember
Mrs Rider as a beginner has a Casio Privia and it sounds great. Weighted key action is impressive, even for the budget model. I bought used so we had money left over for lessons. Worth thinking about. Also, there are very good deals around
Read some reviews?Posted 4 months ago
You must be logged in to reply to this topic.