Email today from CTC following up the appeal case, some interesting points below, pretty much covered the comments made in the thread on here at the time:
At yesterday’s hearing, the Solicitor General for Scotland, Ms Lesley Thomson, argued that the sentence imposed by Sheriff Scott was unduly lenient. It was argued that the sheriff did not give sufficient weight to McCourt’s previous conviction for killing George Dalgity.
It was also argued that Sheriff Scott’s conclusion that Mrs Fyfe’s death was caused by McCourt’s momentary lapse of concentration was erroneous as McCourt had in fact not looked when he made the fatal manouvre and, therefore, the degree of culpability apportioned to him should have been greater.
Finally, the Solicitor General argued that Sheriff Scott should not have considered the fact that Mrs Fyfe was not wearing a helmet at the time of the collision to be mitigatory as he did not have sufficient knowledge to support the inference that a helmet would have saved her life.
Ms Thomson argued that the starting point for sentencing should have been 8 months imprisonment. The Crown also said McCourt should be given a life-time driving ban. The Fyfe family do not want to see McCourt sent to prison, but want him to be banned from driving for life. Only then can he be prevented from injuring or killing any other road users.