Just to present the other side of the ownership love…
I really loved the Cotic’s small diameter steel tubes and for me the frame was a beauty to look at from a distance… but (you knew there was a ‘but’, right?) there are some really poor design flaws (IMO) which over a surprisingly brief time got on my tits so much I ended up selling it – which is a shame, as I still really loved the overall look of it.
– Unless you’re running discs the bolt-on canti bosses are an ugly Heath-Robinson abomination that can at best be described as an a’fterthought’. They detract from the visual beauty of the rest of the frame. Horrible.
– The 2 bottle cage mounts on the down tube is just annoying. It looks wrong, feels wrong, the top one makes inserting/removing even short 500ml bottles tricky.. I mean, come on – what was wrong with a bottle on the ST and another on the DT like every other bike??? Cy’s rationale of placing one bottle higher up the DT when actually shouldering the bike in a CX race doesn’t wash – no-one uses bottles in a CX race anyway. The bottle cage placings are just plain naff.
– The steerer tube angle is very slack compared to other CX bikes. OK, it’s only 1 degree – but try riding an X back-2-back versus other CX bikes and there is a very noticeable ponderous nature to the steering.
– Rear spacing at 135mm. OK, for those of you who want disc brakes on a CX machine (and it does seem the market is going that way) you’ll love it. But for traditionalists and those who actually race CX (how many disc-equipped bikes do you see racing??) it limits your choices as to wheel sets. I had my Cotic X just over 1 year ago, and while there has been a noticeable increase in availability of 135mm-hubbed 700c rimmed wheels, it’s still somewhat limiting.
– Finally, it’s heavy as a pig.
I’d love one if it were built out of better quality tubing, had a better fork, a steeper HA giving sharper steering, bottle bosses in the right places and canto bosses befitting a good frame rather than something from Fisher-Price.