I’m relatively new to Leftys but that doesn’t sound like a reset to me. AFAIK reset is just to correct bearing migration and the usual symptom of needing a reset is reduced travel. Worth trying that first, though.
Also are you telling me you’ve never reset it?!? Mine needs a reset about every 20 hours of riding. Very easy to do, as described above (though I always pull / extend the fork rather than compressing it) If it’s a few years old it’s probably worth sending it to TF tuned or Thumbprint (presuming you are in the UK) for a service anyway – Lefty’s last a long time if you look after them regularly.
I would look here for the best info:
http://forums.mtbr.com/cannondale/
As Drofluf said, post your issues in a thread there and Mendon will usually give you some helpful advice.