It’s got allen key bolt head rounding written all over it.
Recently changed the front axle on my wife’s Cannondale Topstone as that had started to get mangled, despite being very careful it didn’t like being removed multiple times to fit in a fork mount. Replaced with a Brand X one with lever.
Looking on the Topstone FB group it’s a common issue on the Cannondale axles.
Today I learnt that people correctly torque their front axles.
My torquing is done with a short Allen key to make sure I can get it undone again with a multi tool. It’s surprising how easy it is to “overtighten” them with a normal length Allen key.