I always used to like Manitou forks back in the day – their damping was ahead of everyone else’s, but there was always something weird or plastic that shouldn’t have been
I’ll give you that. My son had a pair of Mattocs on his Grantie Chief, and my goodness they were good, but the design of the rebound damper meant, even following instructions, it got lost at least once a year.
Also, air has to be put in/extracted whilst upside down.
On my Mastodon Pro’s, there is an issue that the steerer was not properly seated in the crown – now a well documented feature (but tragic to read back through the confused MTBR mastodon thread) – and initially every ride required a nip up of the pre-load as it slowly bedded. On really big hits (like my OTB incident last week), it still beds in a bit further.
HOWEVER – goddam they are better feeling forks than Fox/RS – just lovely motion and damping, stiff and nicely carvable through the rough stuff. Recommended highly if you can find any 🙂