I have a Hustler and love it, sorry to hear about yours getting nicked.
Shortly after I got mine, I went along to a demo day at my local bike shop and tried loads of models, hoping none would be as good as the Cove.
None were, in my opinion. However that included the Foxy R which I just didn't get the same buzz from riding as I did from the Cove. It's still a good bike with some decent specs and fun to ride but not as good as the Hustler in my opinion. The value is pretty good though.
My brother who works at the shop has a basic Foxy which he uses at the moment. The first time he tried it he wasn't that impressed but now he has it set up and has been riding it more he really likes it.
You ought to give one a shot and see what you think!