Viewing 26 posts - 1 through 26 (of 26 total)
  • Another cracked ti frame?
  • lobby_dosser
    Free Member

    Crack

    Approx 12 years old road bike (On one Lynskey built) noticed this as I set it up on an indoor trainer. What’s the collective thoughts? (I’ve already done some trials but i’m no Hambini)

    Blackflag
    Free Member

    As someone who has just ordered a Ti Camino all these cracked Ti threads are really helping my mood.

    MoreCashThanDash
    Full Member

    Could be worse, you could have a Laverack sized order on its way! 🤞

    Fresh Goods Friday 696: The Middling Edition

    Fresh Goods Friday 696: The Middlin...
    Latest Singletrack Videos
    cynic-al
    Free Member

    Not a crack

    Other materials are possible to crack or not also 🙂

    DaveyBoyWonder
    Free Member

    As someone who has just ordered a Ti Camino all these cracked Ti threads are really helping my mood.

    Its ok, a titanium frame is a frame for life.

    singlespeedstu
    Full Member

    That looks to me like an overlap where the weld ended over the top of the start.

    intheborders
    Free Member

    As someone who has just ordered a Ti Camino all these cracked Ti threads are really helping my mood.

    How many bikes have you had since 2008?

    lobby_dosser
    Free Member

    That looks to me like an overlap where the weld ended over the top of the start.

    That’s what I was thinking, however I wasnt sure if it was a crack starting to propagate from that area. I had never noticed it before until it was hooked up to the turbo trainer and I was worried my lardy arse had broken it.

    lobby_dosser
    Free Member

    Dye applied

    Applied some dye penetrant

    Dye wiped off

    cleaned off excess

    All clear?

    Looks like its hunky dory. Looks like theres a wee bit of undercut.

    Onzadog
    Free Member

    And…breath!

    breadcrumb
    Full Member

    Looks like the weld didn’t penetrate at that point. Seeing as it’s been like that for 12 years I wouldn’t worry too much.

    DezB
    Free Member

    Other materials are possible to crack or not also

    Being a wild and crazy guy, I’d go as far as to say more frames don’t crack than do crack 😛

    Davesport
    Full Member

    Ok, I used to be a “crack inspector” :o) in a specialist part of the O & G industry. So bike frames & Ti not my speciality. Looks like a bit of cold lap & imperfect weld profile. Using Dye-pen is a valid means of detecting surface breaking defects but the correct procedure needs following. Ignoring the dye-pen result & looking at the picture I’d say there’s probably nothing to get excited about.

    lobby_dosser
    Free Member

    ‘crack inspector’ … haha did you have a business card? Thanks for the replies. The reason I was concerned was that I hadn’t noticed it in a decade and all of a sudden when I start using it on the trainer. I’m always a wee bit nervous on the trainer as i’m sure the twisting forces cant be that great for bikes.

    argee
    Full Member

    Wouldn’t say it was a crack as you’ve already heard, but whenever i’ve done dye penetrant, it’s been under UV to then clearly see what residue is left, not seeing that from the pics?

    reeksy
    Full Member

    ““crack inspector” :o) in a specialist part of the O & G industry”
    I work in a hospital. That took me a while to untangle!

    Davesport
    Full Member

    ““crack inspector” :o) in a specialist part of the O & G industry”
    I work in a hospital. That took me a while to untangle!

    Glad you managed to decipher my shorthand. Should have thought before I hit the “post” button !

    lobby_dosser
    Free Member

    but whenever i’ve done dye penetrant, it’s been under UV to then clearly see what residue is left, not seeing that from the pics

    if there’s no penetrant after developing, means there wasnt a crack it was hiding in?

    haggis1978
    Full Member

    Sorry OP but that’s shoddy Lynskey welding for you from a time when their frames were cracking left, right and centre round seattubes. Having said that it is just shoddy welding and not a crack. Ride and enjoy.

    Joe
    Full Member

    Still have no idea why people buy ti frames. What a headache.

    sandwicheater
    Full Member

    Can the mods at ‘STW Official Crack Inspector’ to @Davesport user name? oh go on, I’ll be your friend.

    sillyoldman
    Full Member

    Good Ti is great, but there’s a reason it’s expensive. Shame that it’s reputation is tarnished by poor quality stuff.

    downshep
    Full Member

    Headache free owner of a 1997 Airborne Lucky Strike. Only work it has ever had was disc tabs welded on by Vernon Barker a few years later. 23 years on and I creak more than it does. Expect it will see me out.

    kiwijohn
    Full Member

    Joe

    Still have no idea why people buy ti frames. What a headache.

    I have 8 cracked aluminium swing arms & 2 front triangles on my wall in 8 years.
    & yet it’s my 25 year old Ti HT I should worry about?

    solarider
    Free Member

    Copying a response to another recent thread:

    Stuff breaks from time to time – all materials, all manufacturers, regardless of cost. No ti manufacturer claims that ti is ‘for life’ – it is a common assumption, but frankly standards will date a frame and make it unusable more likely than failure. My first ti bike had a 1 inch headset, rim brakes, 135 QR spacing and whatever the opposite of long/low/slack geometry is!

    There are things that can be done to lessen the failure rate (design, manufacturing, materials etc), but they cost more. On the whole there is a relationship between price and quality and warranty. I say on the whole to avoid offending some folks. That doesn’t mean that cheap products are worse. It means that the time, materials and money required to guarantee quality a longer warranty and the support structure required to facilitate it just costs more, and this is reflected in the price.

    Cheaper products generally (but again not in every case) carry a lesser warranty for a reason. Taking the appropriate care during manufacturing a ti frame does take longer and this is reflected in the price. Brands such as 22, Seven, Moots etc that offer a lifetime warranty do so because their failure rate is low. They also manufacture their frames in house so they can monitor quality during manufacture more easily and deal with repairs directly, more cost effectively and tend to repair rather than replace.

    I have ridden Sevens and Moots for years. Never had one crack. I have however broken carbon and aluminium frames in the same timescale.

    haggis1978
    Full Member

    Exactly what Solarider (or his copy and paste job) says.

    The term frame for life originated in the early 90’s I believe when MTBing was in its infancy and we were just blasting down single-track. Not smashing off of 4,5 & 6 ft drops however many times per ride. Plus there are so many cheap Ti frames out there surely people must acknowledge they’re not built to the same standards as the top tier ones are. A Hyundai is made from metal and plastic. So is a Ferrari.

    I would far rather buy an expensive steel frame than a cheap Ti one.

Viewing 26 posts - 1 through 26 (of 26 total)

The topic ‘Another cracked ti frame?’ is closed to new replies.