Countzero, I beg to differ. Technically, The Stranglers were part of the 70’s pubrock scene, so they were to punk what pulp were to Britpop. A lot of the other acts you mentioned were “New-Wave” rather than punk. Pure “punk” acts weould be more like the Pistols, Clash, Damned, Adverts, Slits, Buzzcocks, Ramones. Punk was dead by ’77, with a number of bigger acts having “sold out”, split up and the new wave acts were in the ascendency. having siad that they sold out, not many of them weren’t in it for the money…
Well, yeah, particularly with hindsight, but when I was going to see them, it was all ‘punk’, but I was never a punk, just a guy with 501’s, converse baseball boots, and a leather bike jacket, which meant I kind of fitted in regardless, and US and UK punk was different to an extent. I’ve always kinda struggled with musical genres anyway, I like what I like, a label is for someone else to worry about, although it does make it a bit easier to find in the racks!
But I do take your point, although I still think that Punk/New Wave has left behind a far greater legacy of good music that is still being played thirty seven years on, compared to how much is still played from the Britpop period; even the better stuff, Elastica, Kenickie, Lush, Echobelly, which, to use your point, aren’t really Britpop, rarely get played even on 6Music, sadly.
Thinking about it, Talking Heads* first album ’77, while sitting in the right timeframe, certainly isn’t punk, far too arty, same with Television, right time, but too clever by ‘alf, really. 😀
Damn, could play games with music genres all night, and just go round in ever decreasing circles, it largely comes down to semantics, I guess. Look at Billy Bragg, really he’s a folky, but was considered sort of punk to start with, and what about John Cooper Clark, he’s a poet!
*And they had Dire Straits as support when I saw them! At least Television had Blondie and the Cortinas… 😉