• This topic has 6,282 replies, 176 voices, and was last updated 4 years ago by kelvin.
Viewing 40 posts - 1,241 through 1,280 (of 6,291 total)
  • 2019 General Election
  • tjagain
    Full Member

    Could this possibly be the election where politicians who lie get found out?

    Johnson is such a proven liar that everything he says is now fact checked – perhaps a trend thats happening because of Trump?

    I have a lot of respect for Sturgeon ( despite not agreeing on all SNP policy) because she ( at least sounds like) she believes what she says and tells the truth as she sees it. I have never heard another politician who when asked an awkward question is prepared to answer: ( I paraphrase) ” I am not sure. My personal instinct is “A”. the party is going to produce a policy on this but has not done so yet, there are no easy answers to this issue”

    I think the contrast between Corbyns thoughtful answers to questions ( see Guardianlive) compared to Johnsons bluff and bluster will become more apparent. ad the pundits seem happier to challenge the lies

    Am I just being too hopeful but today seeing the tories on the defensive and reacting to issues and Corbyn giving thoughtful answers brings me hope that we might be reaching the point where thoughful and truthful politicians may trimph over bluff, bluster, lies and soundbites

    frankconway
    Full Member

    From BBC political correspondent……’Jeremy Corbyn setting a high bar for future Labour government. Says it would be judged on;

    – Whether in work poverty exists in 5 years
    – Whether people still sleeping rough in 5 years
    – Whether people still rely on food banks in 5 years
    – Whether is Brexit sorted in 6 months’

    Answers, in order, are – yes, yes, yes, no.

    On a different subject, Alun Cairns just resigned as Sec of State for Wales; his intention to stand as MP not yet known.

    MSP
    Full Member

    Correct me if I am wrong?

    You wrong.

    Firstly I was responding to your quote that pensions own the majority of companies, which is just so incredibly wrong to be an outright lie.

    Secondly, as the freemarket share ownership has failed to deliver shares into the hands of the many as Thatcher era propaganda promised, this policy increases to percentage of shares owned by the many from 3 to 13%. As an average member of society you are not losing 10% of the piffling amount you have, you are gaining 10% of the whole pot. Still the vast majority will be owned by the 1%ers as now, but it will look just a little more even.

    tjagain
    Full Member

    That Cairns resignation is another piece of chaos in the tory campaign. couldn’t have come at a better time.

    tjagain
    Full Member

    We also have the ASA banning a nine week advertising campaign about universal credit as its misleading. Now clearly that was intended as election material disguised as an information campaign but is yet another example of tory lies that has been exposed

    https://www.theguardian.com/society/2019/nov/06/dwp-misleading-universal-credit-uncovered-ad-banned

    stevextc
    Free Member

    This is not a value judgement on if the policy is right or wrong. Just we need to be clear on the maths here.

    Two things would worry me though not really relevant as only the Libdems stand a chance in my constituency…
    1) A lot of maths… not just this but spending our way out of a recession …
    2) Whatever Jeremy has planned it is so far left of Sweden/Denmark it can’t be done in the EU

    stevextc
    Free Member

    Could this possibly be the election where politicians who lie get found out?

    Johnson is such a proven liar that everything he says is now fact checked – perhaps a trend thats happening because of Trump?

    …. and

    A high percentage of Brexiteers don’t actually care if it’s true or not.

    tjagain
    Full Member

    The business insider ( not a publication I know but sounds like it should be a tory friend) is now leading with Russian money flowing into the tory party. this is a story that is going to keep on running I bet. Suppressing the report on Russian interference and accepting huge sums of money from Putins pals!

    Boris Johnson’s Conservative Party has received a surge in donations from Russians in recent months.
    Donors with ties to Putin have donated hundreds of thousands of pounds to the party.
    They have previously paid for meetings with senior government figures including Johnson.
    The figures come as Johnson blocks publication of a report into potential Russian influence over recent UK elections.
    Johnson’s senior strategist Dominic Cummings is also under the spotlight following reports about time he spent in Russia in the 1990s.

    https://www.businessinsider.com/boris-johnsons-conservatives-receive-surge-in-cash-from-russians-2019-11?r=US&IR=T&fbclid=IwAR30GMG81LCQ1HV59gyHJUcsrUYpZojvnd2NkusOXDwnX13NJYa3WPDhsfU

    tjagain
    Full Member

    Whatever Jeremy has planned it is so far left of Sweden/Denmark it can’t be done in the EU

    Really? Name one such ting please.

    kerley
    Free Member

    The liars (seem to be Tories) have been getting found out since Johnson became PM. Unfortunately as stevextc points out, it doesn’t matter to a lot of people. The very people they insult keep voting for them.
    Very much the Trump “I could shoot someone on 5th Avenue and people would still vote for me”

    stevextc
    Free Member

    The liars (seem to be Tories) have been getting found out since Johnson became PM. Unfortunately as stevextc points out, it doesn’t matter to a lot of people. The very people they insult keep voting for them.
    Very much the Trump “I could shoot someone on 5th Avenue and people would still vote for me”

    Way before that … way before the brexit bus… he’s been spouting obvious lies for decades.. “bananas” … and when it turns out to be false ??? “oh well it could be true”

    tjagain
    Full Member

    The ideological tories and breixteers are not enough to get Johnson a majority. He needs to convert people to his cause. Playing to the 30% that support anything you say is not enough. He has to gain millions of votes to get a majority. Its these swing voters that count and lying surely puts them off?

    cchris2lou
    Full Member

    I think it is changing, and the liers are challenged and scutanised.
    They got away in 2016, they won’t in 2019.
    Even Corbyn seems to be on the ball.

    stevextc
    Free Member

    Really? Name one such ting please.

    You already named one .. stealing 10% off businesses but that is not really the point I’m making.

    He’s an ardent Leaver because the EU is too capitalist and restrictive for his red unicorn.
    As Sweden and Denmark seem to be able to exist perfectly well within the EU his red unicorn must be well left of them.

    Personally I’d like to see a Swedish style socialism in the UK but whatever Corbyn has in his head is obviously not that.

    martinhutch
    Full Member

    NOpe – I think thats a bit of futile debate and I wanted this thread to move on.

    Please everyone, respect TJ’s inherent correctness on this issue and move along peaceably.

    bazzer
    Free Member

    As an average member of society you are not losing 10% of the piffling amount you have, you are gaining 10% of the whole pot. Still the vast majority will be owned by the 1%ers as now, but it will look just a little more even.

    To use your phraseology, so wrong its almost a lie. The £500 cap per person means that the man in the street won’t get another 10% of the value of the companies, it will get a small share with the government getting the rest.

    kelvin
    Full Member

    Boris is outside no10 repeating all his Vote Leave nonsense, and complaining and pointing the finger of blame at MPs voting against Withdrawal Agreements (which he did twice, and many of his government did three times).

    (And now it’s all about immigration again. And pretending Brexit is put to bed this year if you vote for him.)

    kelvin
    Full Member

    (He sounds a bit rubbish, doesn’t he.)

    (Repeating already fully debunked lies about new hospitals, and some weird claim that the Labour’s replacement for Ofsted would mean your kids getting beaten up at school – get used to this.)

    bazzer
    Free Member

    @MSP its a wealth tax nothing more and nothing less.

    I am not sure what my position is on wealth tax if I am honest. I can can see the benefit to help pay for services etc. I however can also see that it could drive wealth out of the country.

    martinhutch
    Full Member

    that the Labour’s replacement for Ofsted would mean your kids getting beaten up at school

    Well, he is somewhat of an expert in helping to get people beaten up.

    dazh
    Full Member

    Repeating already fully debunked lies about new hospitals, and some weird claim that the Labour’s replacement for Ofsted would mean your kids getting beaten up at school – get used to this.

    I think the themes of the tory campaign so far are hubris, complacency and entitlement, not to mention incompetence and chaos. They really do seem to think they can win by default on account of not being Jeremy Corbyn. They’re going to s*** themselves when the news starts reporting on Corbyn rallies with thousands of people. I’m trying not to be too optimistic but it’s looking very much like a rerun of 2017.

    tjagain
    Full Member

    Certainly the early signs look good for labour and the tories are reacting to events and having to apologise for multiple things. Tories are certainly on the back foot.

    martinhutch
    Full Member

    I’m trying not to be too optimistic but it’s looking very much like a rerun of 2017.

    Conservatives largest party and Labour a distant second? I’d hate to see what your pessimistic outlook is!

    kimbers
    Full Member

    Moving on to Juncker’s interview with Katya Adler – ‘and he said he did not think Labour’s pledge to renegotiate the withdrawal agreement if it wins a majority in the general election was a realistic approach – although this would be an issue for his successor’.
    Sure, he’s on his way out but I doubt he is talking out of turn.

    nah Juncker wants a brexit deal done as part of his legacy, and he doesnt speak for the council of ministers- Im sure theyd be very pleased with that

    as for what a Labour brexit would look like……… a lot of fluff & drama but theyll never get to stop FOM & keep SM acces they want, so it will be a Norway deal

    which could be signed off far quicker as its off the shelf

    which would be an interesting referendum vs remain!

    outofbreath
    Free Member

    as the freemarket share ownership has failed to deliver shares into the hands of the many as Thatcher era propaganda promised, this policy increases to percentage of shares owned by the many from 3 to 13%.

    So you agree they are going to sequester 10pc of all uk firms over 250fte. A policy so insane that there are people in this thread who don’t even believe in it.

    2) Whatever Jeremy has planned it is so far left of Sweden/Denmark it can’t be done in the EU

    This. They have a policy of preventing the inevitable capital capital flight with controls which are incompatible with EU free movement of capital.

    these swing voters that count and lying surely puts them off?

    Yes, but not nearly as much as having 10pc of their pension confiscated.

    molgrips
    Free Member

    whatever Corbyn has in his head is obviously not that.

    But as we know, Labour party policy is not set by the leader…

    CaptainFlashheart
    Free Member

    When’s the EHRC report due?

    kelvin
    Full Member

    Conservatives largest party and Labour a distant second? I’d hate to see what your pessimistic outlook is!

    If Labour can match their MP count from 2017, and both SNP and LibDems can increase their MP count, if only by single figures, then that is a far far better result than Johnson getting the majority he has called this election to try and get. PC, Greens and independents might also grab a few Tory seats if people get smart with their votes. This is pretty much the best result we can hope for, and currently still looking very unlikely… let’s hope the next few weeks see that change… there are nuggets of current news that you cling on to for hope at least.

    stevextc
    Free Member

    But as we know, Labour party policy is not set by the leader…

    TBH leader is like a sheep leading the goats in this case but not what the UK needs right now (is it?). In terms of election though he has lost millions of voters (it’s a bit academic for me as LibDems are way ahead locally) but many traditional soft Labour voters (i.e. possible swing voters) have just melted away.

    molgrips
    Free Member

    TBH leader is like a sheep leading the goats in this case but not what the UK needs right now (is it?)

    Labour party has a democratic process. This is how it’s always been isn’t it? It seems reasonable to me, I’d rather that than one nutjob ruling the whole place.

    Sure, momentum have dragged the party leftwards but then we’re back to the problem with FPTP as most people don’t have their own political home do they? We all have to house-share.

    molgrips
    Free Member

    A policy so insane that there are people in this thread who don’t even believe in it.

    You’re determined to interpretet the reports you’ve read in the worst possible light. It’s not even published policy yet, there isn’t even a manifesto. Hold your fire.

    kelvin
    Full Member

    Hold your fire.

    So we ignore anything said ‘till we read the manifestos? That’ll mean no critiques of anything Brexit Party related then… as they’ll be avoiding writing anything down in a manifesto, I suspect.

    kimbers
    Full Member

    oh dear despite all the talk of cleaning up politics & parliament & a new speaker etc

    this election is setting a very bad tone so far

    tories & their brexit have driven off many of the moderates from the Tories & many of the women that cameron made such an effort to bring on board (momemntum have done similar in Labour, but theyre just not as good at metaphorically knifing their own as tories)

    Bridgen jumping to Moggs defence when he really shouldnt was a good example of this tribalism trumping compassion or indeed common sense.

    Leading Welsh Tory quits for lying about his pal sabotaging a rape trial
    Telegraph front page comparing Corbyn to Stalin killing 6 million Kulaks
    Cleverly running away from kay burley & Tory lapdog guido immediately leaping to his defence- lying that he was at the time talking to wannabe Hopkins on LBC
    Tories editing that starmer video has now seen this…..

    Tories editing that starmer video has now led to parodies too

    stevextc
    Free Member

    Labour party has a democratic process. This is how it’s always been isn’t it? It seems reasonable to me, I’d rather that than one nutjob ruling the whole place.

    It’s a form of democracy … and ignoring the union block votes for now it doesn’t seem supportable as a way to run a country. I’m guessing you too remember the 70’s…? but equally the Soviet union or places like Cuba, Libya soon dispatched with democracy in order to get anything done.

    It’s perhaps sad but human nature seems to get in the way …

    You’re determined to interpretet the reports you’ve read in the worst possible light. It’s not even published policy yet, there isn’t even a manifesto. Hold your fire.

    That is what most of the electorate will do….

    tjagain
    Full Member

    ctually I think much of the electorate that labour are aiming at will see the policy as positive.

    outofbreath
    Free Member

    You’re determined to interpretet the reports you’ve read in the worst possible light. It’s not even published policy yet, there isn’t even a manifesto. Hold your fire.

    I’m not talking about “reports”, and I’m not interpreting anything. You can hear it yourself on the link above. It’s been announced at the same time as “Warm Homes for all” and the “Nationalization at a Fair rate” policy. You can hear RLB quizzed on it so there’s no room for misunderstanding.

    The FT have run analysis on it.

    …but let’s just remember for future reference that this policy is so mental that when they first heard about it several people literally didn’t even believe it.

    dazh
    Full Member

    Conservatives largest party and Labour a distant second?

    In 2017 labour had a much larger majority to overhaul and were very much on the back foot at the start of the campaign. It’s very different this time. Quite frankly I’m equally surprised at the slickness of labour’s early campaign and the chaos of the tories. Even the media have been broadly positive about labour and scathing towards the tories and the equal coverage campaign rules haven’t even kicked in yet.

    tjagain
    Full Member

    OOB – yes the FT ran an analysis as have others and its nothing like what you keep on claiming.

    kelvin
    Full Member

    What’s all this about?

    tjagain
    Full Member

    OOB – one thing among many you are ( deliberatly?) misunderstanding is that the Labour government will pay for these shares not simply take them. so of course that negates most of your rather hysterical argument

    All we have at the moment is an outline of the plan. No details.

Viewing 40 posts - 1,241 through 1,280 (of 6,291 total)

The topic ‘2019 General Election’ is closed to new replies.