I bought some of the bike-discount Polaris boots. damn comfy, roomy toe section whilst keeping the rest of your foot snug. I’m liking the cleat mount with extra support too, seems to minimise ankle roll.
As a winter boot they’re nice and warm, however they are not totally waterproof. The shoe itself is, and is great for keeping the elements out of the cleat holes etc, but the ankle cuff is split, so leaks water in fairly easily.
It’s a shame really, if it were complete neoprene cuff it then water would at least not get in quite as easily.
Otherwise, the only winter boot I’ve had where I’ve not got cold feet.
Worth the cash to be honest, I found the shimano boots a little too bulky.
Oh, and make sure you size up one size.