I’ve just spent a lot of money working through a load of different lubes after Rock N’ Roll Extreme disappeared for a while! I know it’s a personal preference and terrain/weather dependant thing with chain lube but here’s my little list I’ve worked through:
Muc Off Wet: great for short rides and if you use it sparingly. Any longer than 15 or so miles and it either disappears in the wet or gums up everything if it’s even remotely dry. Awful in reasonably dry conditions, just acts like velcro for every bit of dirt going!
Fenwicks Stealth Extreme: Very good in pretty much all conditions. Did over 80 miles on it in mixed conditions (L-B offroad) without having to top-up. Doesn’t get gooey unless you load on too much. Sadly no longer made 🙁
Morgan Blue Syn Lube: Nearly as good as the Fenwicks Stealth but does goo up easier in dry conditions. Great in the wet and on the commuter bike when used sparingly.
Juice Lubes Wet: Sticky, horrible and doesn’t last in the wet!
Pedro’s Ice Wax: great in the dry, useless in anything remotely wet ie not suitable for Wales.
Muc Off Team Sky Hydrodynamic: works well in most conditions but doesn’t last long when it’s really gritty. Mahoosively expensive!!
Rock N’ Roll Extreme: Lasts forever. Runs silent for the first 20 miles or so then you start to hear the rollers rattling a bit. It then carries on working for ever, seemingly! Only managed to get the chain squeaking once after two sopping wet rides in a row and I forgot to reapply it. Keeps the chain near spotless. Happily it’s now available again from Ribble 😀
All of that is from mainly riding a mix of trail centres and natural all over Wales and FOD etc.
Forks, shock and dropper get Juice Lubes spray every time. Best out there by a mile and lasts aeons.