I recently replaced a set of 2011 fox 36 talas 160mm forks with some 2013 marzocchi 55 rc3 Ti Evo 2. Only had them a couple of weeks, but have given them a fair amount of hammer over 4 days of lift assisted riding in southern spain.
They are loads better than the fox at smoothing out small bumps, they dont blow through the travel under braking/bigger bumps. I’d definitely recommend them if smoothing out the trail is your number 1 requirement above all else.
In terms of criticisms:-
– They are a little heavier (only 200grams though) than the fox
– the coil spring does not allow loads of spring rate adjustment if you’re significantly heaver or lighter than average.
– Despite what the marzocchi website implies, the high and low speed compression is not independently adjustable. You adjust compression damping with a single knob, you increase low speed compression and high speed compression decreases and vice versa. No idea why they’ve done this, but to be honest it doesnt seem to be a real problem. the performance is excellent, but you cant set high and low speed compression independently.