Viewing 7 posts - 1 through 7 (of 7 total)
  • What replacement GPS?
  • chalkstorm
    Free Member

    Hi all
    Been using a Garmin Edge 305 for a couple of years. Really like the heart rate monitor and training functions – but dislike the ‘100 waypoints’ – which limits what I can plan accurately.
    Anyway, did C2C at the weekend, and like a right knob, watched my 305 bounce along the quayside at Whitehaven into the harbour… only landed in 2′ of water but impossible to reach without a swim…
    Any recommendations on replacements?
    Thanks

    geoffj
    Full Member

    Get the Edge 705. You can do the route to course fix which allows you to navigate longer routes easier.
    The Garmin Oregon 300 has HR and Cadence sensor compatability, but the screen is carp and its too big.

    Nick
    Full Member

    go for a swim

    grumm
    Free Member

    Can’t believe you didn’t try and get it back!

    djglover
    Free Member

    you can plan a route on garmin with tracks using 500 points, well you can using bikehike.co.uk and uploading to garmin. the site even truncates longer tracks to 500 points for you.

    Paceman
    Free Member

    Satmap Active 10 ?

    Digimap
    Free Member

    Chalkstorm, there’s some confusion in these posts about what you can do with the Edges. The waypoints in an Edge aren’t intended for route planning, that’s why there are only 100. They are handy for marking stuff whilst out on the trail but that’s it.

    The Edge 305 has courses as it’s primary navigation method. A course is just like a track but with timings added for the virtual partner (which paces you around the loop). A course can take many thousands of points so at about 10 points per mile average you can plan very long fully detailed routes. To use courses you need software that can transfer courses to the device, TrackLogs v3.x does this and autogenerates the virtual partner timings for you based on Naismith and the elevation of your track. The only problem with the Edge305 is it was the last of the Garmins to use serial communication and the first to support courses so it’s out on a limb and may not be that future proof but it is small and does the job. Go for a swim and get it!

    The Edge 705 works on the same principle as the 305 in that you navigate with courses only this time they are saved direct to the unit in the Garmin TCX (or .crs) format. To use this you need software which can save these files (e.g. TrackLogs v3.13.x). The Edge705 does also support routes but it’s currently flawed as the firmware does some point filtering which renders the uploaded routes unreliable. There’s also nothing in route navigation which can’t be done with a course. The Edge 705 is my preferred GPS at the moment on and off road, it’s a little larger than the 305.

Viewing 7 posts - 1 through 7 (of 7 total)

The topic ‘What replacement GPS?’ is closed to new replies.