Last week bought 5 pairs from CRC to try on.
Nukeproof – the most comfortable, but thick neoprene means they’d be too hot in summer.
Troy Lee, 5400 – comfy but too minimal on protection. Zero padding on the sides ans I was after some side protection.
661 Rage (i think) – not that comfy and the knee pad stuck out for miles. Don’t know if they would mould to the knee, but weren’t that comfy in the wander about the house and do leg lifts test.
IXS Hack – knee pad was very soft and didn’t seem to offer protection if the others.
Alpinestars – very close in comfort to the nukeproof. Mesh round the back of the knee to keep relatively cool. Decent padding on knee and sides. These are the ones I’ll keep.
Alpinestars for the win. All the above are around 45 quid.
The Alpinestars are replacing a 4 year old pair of Pocs which are very good but have now gone baggy and slide down in a get off.