might be biased as it is my local. but i like the way ae makes you work hard to get round it. if you want a gentle day riding up and down smooth trails then it is not the place for you. it is a hard fitness route, but the remote feeling you get on that trail is pretty special i feel. i agree with the curry paste comments though- it is a bit of a strange surface, and not much fun in the wet.
for a few weeks now i have done their saturday trail maintanance days. we have been working on the granny green luv sections. although i too was a bit dubious about the 'smoothening' of the trail, i have ridden a few times since and think that it is actually required. after all it is only a countouring piece of singletrack- so does not need to be a technical descent or challenging climb. there are enough sections that have become rocky enough for a challenge elsewhere (e.g. the descent down to the face, and the face itself). i don't think the trail maintanance is taking anything away from ae. for non-regular weekend warrior riders the smoothening of the trail is required because ae is such a tough workout.
maybe it doesn't have the technical challenge or flow of some of the other stanes, but this makes ae unique. tbh i love it. the fact it is not like every other trail centre makes it stand out. like marmite, some will not like it, but then that is up to you.
the cafe at the end is a great addition now, and i hope it will bring in more riders to boost their income and ability to maintain trails in the future.