I have the Endura Luminite gloves which Cyclescheme sent me to review. My hands were cold yesterday morning at about -2 or -3 on a road bike averaging about 18mph. They did eventually warm up after 30 minutes or so but initially they were cold. I tried them with liners this morning which was much warmer obviously. I’ve not tried them in the rain yet so can’t say how waterproof they are. My only gripe with them is the cuff is a little short and if I don’t pull your base layer all the way down my wrists are cold.
I also have a pair of Sealskinz Winter gloves. You can buy them at various thermal ratings, mine are 4 with 5 being the warmest. These cope with -2 or -3 without the need of a liner and are 100% waterproof, as long as you make sure your jacket is over the cuff 😉 The cuffs are longer than the Luminite gloves and keep my wrists warm. These are the first “waterproof” gloves that I can honestly say are 100% waterproof and I’ve tried quite a few including older versions of Sealskinz.
I’ve tried Aldi gloves and while they are warm with a glove liner I’ve always found that prolonged riding in the rain has resulted in wet hands. Although they are warm wet hands.