Curious on why linseed oil didn’t work. Believe its used for marine goods? What testing did you do?
ISTR I used En3 mild steel grit cleaned to SA 2.5, degreased with Isopropyl alcohol. 7 patches on each sample separated by machined grooves. One patch used as a control, the others coated with the products I was testing. I allowed the products 24 hours to fully adhere then the test piece was then left outside fastened at 45 deg and monitored. I tried the same test with added salt exposure which accelerated the results.
The biggest surprise for me was how quickly the film of anything applied as a liquid broke down and allowed corrosion to start, including the linseed oil. I didn’t try Dinitrol, but the Weagles & Waxoly lasted months as opposed to days.
It’s open to discussion that the environment inside a frame tube is entirely different but the factors involved in corrosion are the same.
Corrosion in the marine environment is a different field. I’ve been involved a wee bit with this over the years. Material selection and coatings are consider from the design stage.
The problem with the Waxoyl was getting it to a suitable consistency at room temperature. It thins down well when diluted with white spirit but still doesn’t flow that well when poured into a cold steel frame. I did try on someone else’s frame and that thing will never rust from the inside out as it’s mostly solid wax 😆
If I was doing this again I’d try the stuff from Ribble.
D