As Rooney approaches, McCarthy appears to position/ready himself to bodycheck Rooney, to prevent him getting past. Doesn’t warrant the elbow, but could be argued that McCarthy was about to foul Rooney, and Rooney decided to deal with it in his own inimitable way.

Ah so that makes it all ok.. 🙄

I’m just trying to explain things within their proper context.

You’re failing but hey then you are trying to defend the indefensible.. 😉

Rooney committed a foul which he got away with. It was either nothing or a red card. It certainly wasnt nothing..

handbaygs

So you think that kind of thing is ok then?

Boys play football, Men play Rugby

Ive played both games & the histrionics in football would be better off on the stage.. The I cant recall seeing anything similar in rugby. Thats not saying it hasnt happened but rugby doesnt appear to get labelled with in the same sense.

If it was on the ball, I may have viewed it slightly differently, but it wasnt, so it was just thuggery.

Ah so that makes it all ok..

No. Where did I say it did? Hmm?

No. Where did I say it did? Hmm?

You didnt but you are trying to defend Rooney’s actions so that suggests that you dont think its a problem..

You didnt but you are trying to defend Rooney’s actions

Give me strength… 🙄

I’m not. I’m just placing them within the context they belong. I’ve already said he was out of order and should have bin sent off, and banned.

Of course, had you bothered to actually read what I wrote propply, you’d know this…

I prefer the eye gouges in rugger.

Oh come on elf – all your talk of passion etc isnt you trying to excuse his behaviour? Yes you said he should have been sent off but you dont think that you arent just even a little bit trying to defend his actions? You even tried to claim that McCarthy was somehow culpable as well!

“Rooney should have enough of a brain”
Post by Tim that made me laugh!

Oh come on elf – all your talk of passion etc isnt you trying to excuse his behaviour?

No. It’s not. It’s trying to understand his behaviour.

🙄

I’m getting bored with this. Anyone else?

nacho – Member

“Rooney should have enough of a brain”
Post by Tim that made me laugh!

Too hopeful you think? 8)

Point is your stance could be interpreted as being defensive of Rooney. You wrote of it only being a little elbow & a touch of argy-bargy & bit of handbags. Thats what I object to. It was an act of thuggery (which we both agree), however you seem to have a different idea as to where the line is drawn.

Care to comment on tonight?

have two codes, like mens and womens lacrosse. One no contact for continental pussies, and one full contact for spud-faced northerners.

You obviously haven’t tried to play a game against czechs then… vicious bastards the lot of ’em brought up on box lacrosse and razor blades…