I also have a couple of Alpkit ‘wannabees’. They are Fat Airic’s (or whatever the latest fatty mat is called) for car camping. Both failed after ~1 year and replaced under warranty.
Alpkit re-jigged its entire mat range quite recently. New models made in a different factory, better quality, replacement for the Fat Airic is called the Dozer. Should be more reliable, mine’s been fine anyway, had leakage around the valve on an early Fat Airic, another, bought at the same time, has been flawless.
American brand called Nemo does an interesting self-inflating mat – two layers with separate valves so you can keep the bottom layer firm to cope with rocks etc while the top layer is softer for comfort.
Oh, and generally, the lighter you go, the more likely you are to have puncture issues – lighter mats use thinner materials, more likely to hole. Carry them inside a pack not hanging off it and beware of itchy grass and similar, particularly if you’re bivvying or using it as an impromptu sun-lounger.