I'm clearly an anorak as I was watching it thinking, this part in the book was far better…I don't think it did the book justice, but I think it did well for the Harry Pooter collection of films…the first 1.45-2 hours was a good built up but the last half hour or so seemed to go by very very quickly and didn't seem as good as the book.
Leaving the book comparisons aside I thought it was ok, not the best but not a flop.
The scenes in the banquet hall and the school were let down by the lack of moving pictures and staircases and food suddenly appearing. I think a few touches were left out to save time and money…didn't detract from the film but did make me realise that I was an anorak as I spotted them instantly…
I wouldn't go to see it again at the cinema but would watch it a few times on DVD again.