I went on a cider mission a couple years ago and tried around 60 varieties in relatively quick succession – with a mate – we concluded that anything aged in oak barrels almost always has a better flavour than those which are not (check the label).
I concur that Westons and Thatchers generally produce good flavours. Aspall too have a couple of winners, although we both thought their organic version tasted awful! (our least favourite)
Too many sulfites tends to make the batch too acidic/bitter on the aftertaste.
Bulmers released a 2012 white labelled ‘Vintage Reserve’ (No.18) which was bloody lovely. Crisp, and bittersweet with a fine fizz. Haven’t seen any in the shops for a year now but still live in hope, would love to find a hidden batch somewhere.
If the craving comes, I usually pick up Thatchers Vintage or Gold, Aspall Vintage, or Henry Westons Vintage.
In fact, i’m off out to the corner shop..