to be fair, unless you are riding in deep snow or very soft sand, 3.8-4 ” rubber on a 50-65mm rim is all you will ever need and actually rides so much better than 5″ on 80mm+ for UK trail conditions.
That’s a bold statement. Have you had much experience riding UK trails on 5″ tyres? As I said above, I don’t know anybody who has ridden 4.0 and 4.8 Jumbo Jims on trails who didn’t prefer the larger ones.
Personally the “look at meeeeeeee” aspect is what I like least about fatbikes. But since I tend to ride on my own, in the middle of nowhere and don’t see anybody all day, it’s not a big issue.
I am 4.0 curious, but I’ve never ridden my 4.8s and thought “I wish these were less fat”. Less comfort, less grip, less confidence ins[iring. None of it sounds like a plus. But, to answer my own question, I’ve not spent much time riding UK trails on 3.8″ tyres, so what do I know 🙂