I don’t get the hard core mtbers hatred of the mudguard, so many times in awful conditions I’ve seen lads go past with nice expensive bikes, no rear mud gaurd and shit all up their back. Content and function over aesthetics every time.
I think there’s an element of objectivenes in it. For just plodding allong they’re fine, but for anythign ganrr they get in the way, snag, snap, swivel round, jam wheels, or just fall off. Over time this has been enshrined in the unofficial ‘rules’, so now people who just want to plod about (thinking they’re gnarr) refuse them.
‘ass defender’, and some inertube between the forks works OK for me. Or various models of chromoplastics and raceblades on the road.