Yes. I had a 5th Element that was 1/2 inch shorter than the air shock that cam with it. Whic hin turn on the 04 model I’ve got is I think 1/4 inch shorter than the coil shock that was the other shock option.
It was alarmingly stable at speed (slacker head angle) plusher (coil v air – no surprise) and clattered the pedals/ crank arms off anything bigger then a pebble – which ran contrary to the ‘go fast downhill’ feel of the thing.
For me – I got bored of pedal strikes. If you can find a cheap shock on here give it a go – or if you’re in Manchester we can try a shock swap for a bit and see how you get on. I won’t be doinbg it again.
Cheers
Paul