With the promised referendum coming soon who should have a say in the referendum, what should the question be and ultimately would Scotland be better off?
Is this like the Euro project a political folly or real progress to improve the lives of the Scottish people.
Having lived and worked in Scotland I have many fond memories and made some great friends ...I could not howver escape some of the anti English sentiment. However I can't help but feel that both England and Scotland would be poorer for it out of the union.
Personally I think the English should have a say (even if not a formal vote) as we are two halves of the same relationship and it would be wrong for one to make a unilateral decision?