WOur region are were going down the line of banning rigger boots, unless i could get a rigger boot which offered similar ankle support as a lace up boot with ankle support. This was following a review of the accident statistics where 70% of RIDDOR accidents involving ankle injury identified that the injured persons were wearing rigger boots.
I have worn riggers, wellies, forge boots, lace up boots, safety trainers, safety shoes since 1991.
Riggers are good in sloppy civils / new build sites where the ground is not capped off. They are crap when the back of the heel starts to sag.
I have sourced a rigger boot which has ankle and heel support, and is also waterproof and insulated. They are Scruffs Cyclone 3’s and i have started wearing them this week. Bit clumsy for first couple of days, then you get used to them. Warm, comfy and waterproof and our site staff who have seen them have asked for me to approve them, so that they can go back to wearing riggers on site. Not much good for refurbishment type works where we are in occupied houses.
I would reccomend these for your brother.
The rigger ban was started by Network rail about 7 years ago – i had quite a few heated debates with their safety managers, asking them to prove that a standar lace up safety boot offered more ankle support.
BTW Doc Martins don’t have a protective mid-sole which is a requirement on most construction sites.