My son is coming up to 3 1/2 and is whizzing all over the place on his Isla Rothan. Was hoping to wait until Christmas to get his first proper bike but it looks as though he’ll outgrow the Rothan in the next couple of months (seat post is at full extension now)
I really like the Rothan and his big sister has just had an Isla Beinn 20″ and it is a very nice bike but at a cost.
We’ve more or less decided that for my Son’s first proper bike we’ll do what we did with our Daughter and get a Ridgeback equivalent of the Isla. Price wise the 16″ is about £40-£50 less than the Isla and to be fair the build quality if good. Alloy frame and wheels, rigid fork, decent v brakes and a good weight overall.
The Islas are really nice but there are others out there which compare quite well too and at the younger ages might work out better.
Once you get into the 20″ wheel and above bracket I’d revert back to the Isla bikes option as that way you avoid the heavy and ineffective fork that you’ll find on comaprable bikes (plus other things)