Mastiles – to get diminished responsibility accepted it’s basically a battle of the psychiatrists, you need various detailed reports saying that you were severely mentally unwell, it isn’t just as easy as saying “diminished responsibility” although it is the “thing to do” at the minute, “the fashion” so to speak.
@ Toys – locking her up will be the only way of (a) protecting the public at this time (which they clearly need to do) and (b) be the sole way of her getting the relevant treatment for her illness.
The other thing is (I’m not sure about Scottish law) but if that was sentencing in English law the 16 year tariff is a time before she can apply for parole. SO it doesn’t mean she will be released after 16 years, that is when she can apply for parole and she will be released pending the parole board thinking she is not a danger to society.
I have just finished working on this case and you think 20 years for that!!
http://www.thesun.co.uk/sol/homepage/news/3539518/Son-hacks-his-mum-to-death-with-a-machete.html