All the big carriers are a bit hit or miss to be honest. I was involved in a really boring project a couple of years ago testing various couriers for picking up and delivering car parts. In short they all had issues and it was just a matter of luck as to whether the service was good.
Why not try Anyvan? I’ve used them a couple of times with good results. It’s basically an independent man-with-a-van matching service so his personal business depends on doing a good job. Just put in your request on their website, wait for bids and check their customer feedback. I find it works well for odd sized or fragile packages. They usually drive straight from your house to the destination without going through a depot, so less chance of being trashed.