That’s why I think the whole thing is about nationalism, pure and simple
If you mean civic nationalism – the idea that Scotland is a nation made up of the people who live here, wherever they’re from, yes. If you think it’s about ethnic background, where you’re born, it really isn’t. I’m the only Scottish-born person in my whole family (apart from 4-year-old daughter) and we’re all voting Yes.
This isn’t about pound and pence for most people, it’s not an unemotional tallying up of the costs one way or another to come to a completely Spock-like rational decision. Of course it isn’t, it isn’t for any decision humans ever make. What it is is about hope, hoping that it’s possible to change things. People voting Yes are hoping that independence will kick-start that change. People I know who are voting No are equally hopeful that staying in the Union we can force change.
Oddly, that reason for voting No is one that’s not heard very often. Probably because the parties in charge of the a Better Together campaign don’t like the implication that things at the moment aren’t brilliant and need radical change. However it’s a point of view I respect even if I don’t agree with it.