There are some good arguments, pro’s and con’s here, and I won’t try to interject anything new here, except to say :-
My first MTB back in about 1995, was a Claude Butler. Ok, but cumbersome, overbuilt and a bit “hard work”.
Then I got a bonus at work, and went to a bike shop with a budget of £400. I tried Specialised Rockhoppers in both steel (ok) ali (awful) and Various Marins. All looked quite smart. Then I saw a little Clockwork in the corner of the shop. Frankly, it looked “plainer” than the others, but somehow “smarter” too. Not sure why or how, but the paint looked good, and the bike seemed to have “kerb appeal”, it was lower, sleeker than anything else I’d tried.
The guy at the shop was really good, let me try out all the bikes I wanted, (Rayment Cycles Brighton, fwiw) and I thought I could just stretch my budget by £100 or so, and asked to try the Clockwork.
Now, I know all the frames were probably taiwanese, but as soon as I put a leg over the clockwork, that was it – it was a bit fast steering for the first few mins till I got used to it, a bit “bambi on ice”, but for the first time, I realy could feel what the “frame” was doing on the bike, the bike just “zipped” with every pedal stroke – it came alive in my hands – even the seating position, further back, a bit less “shopper bike upright”.
Frankly, it was so much better than the other bikes I tried, even with bargain basement alivio kit, that there was no use trying anything else. If I’d had the cash, I wouldn’t have bought a better bike, just a Clockwork with an upgraded component spec.
It was the first bike I’d had since My Diamond Back Silverstreak BMX that really felt “special”.
Thats why I bought my first Orange. – I haven’t quite managed to capture the magic with subsequent p7’s, but they are great workhorses, similar, but just a bit less “zippy” than the Clockwork.
So I buy Oranges as the just seem to work for me. – The P7 I have is a 99 spec bought in a sale in 01, and the finish is fantastically hard wearing – anything bolts to it I could possibly want – it all works, including the wheels which have never needed trueing from factory.
The only reason I am thinking of a change now, is the Pure 7 interests me as it looks more “lightly fabricated” than the p7, ie more like the Clockwork, whilst giving me a modern suspension length up front.
I have tried more modern rockhoppers and even had a Kona Muni Mula, in aly – all good, but none have the magic that my first clockwork had, and that the p7’s have to a lesser extent. I am a slightly odd shape, and Orange’s just seem to fit me better than the rest.
Thats why I buy Orange’s, even knowing that it’s Taiwanese fabrication. It still works bloody well as a bike, and are well built up by their dealers and at the factory.