I think perhaps the only issue with Uncle Dave’s musings is perspective. He’s obviously a bloke who’s world is mountain biking, he writes about it for a website dedicated to it where, no doubt, they are constantly being cajoled and persuaded to look favourably at yet another bit of “innovation” from what has become a significant niche within cycling… But MTBing, especially the glossy, high price point, lifestyle marketed version, isn’t all cycling, or even all that representative of cycling…
I think what the piece tells us more than anything, by looking at the author, is that you can be on the kool aid so long, you start to forget there’s a world outside of it, he’s perhaps noticing the unsustainable aspects of the subset of the cycling world he’s involved in and perhaps starting to examine the difference between ‘want’ and ‘need’…
But these are not groundbreaking revelations…