I ride mainly in Shropshire/FOD, with trips to Peaks/Wales(BPW,Afan,Cwmcarn) so ground varies from mud to rock.
Default front tyre is a Minion DHF, use this pretty much year round, only swapping to a shorty if its been very wet and the ground doesn’t dry well (Bringewood). Recent trip to Peebles, packed the shorty, trails were wet but DHF coped fine (espiecally the ones with lots of roots/rock, where the shorty isn’t great).
I bought a new Shorty back in October, probably have around 8 rides on it, side knobs have lost all their sharpness, not sure how you lot can run them year round without replacing them every couple of months!
Reign is running Minion DHF front and Aggressor rear (bit quicker rolling than a DHF and more braking traction than a minion SS)
Smuggler is Forekaster front/Ardent Race rear for local xc rides, second set of wheels shod with Minion/Minion SS.