Is the weight difference of a Reverb noticeable the first time you hit a hill climb ?
Probably not, it’s not much. Some really attuned people might, or feel a difference in the balance, I suppose- I can’t.
But the trick isn’t so much the first hill climb as the last- that’s when the weight could add up just from extra effort you didn’t notice over the course of the race. Or for that matter where you might find energy saved with the reverb due to easier descending and better conservation of speed pays off. I’m not a proper XC racer tbh but I’ve thought about this over the years of doing endurance type XC and though it definitely does benefit me on the descents where i really feel it is going into the climb after, fresher. And if I can start a climb better I tend to continue better, it’s just psychology.
But that’s just me. If I’d learned the skillset of really riding well with the seat up, I’d maybe feel different. I never will, it’s a useless cul-de-sac, but that means I can’t compare. And not many people can I think.
I can’t imagine the small number of seconds saved with lighter paper thin tyres and lighter wheels can make up for the time it takes to ride a bike back to the pits on a punctured wheel.
Of course it doesn’t- it’s a gamble basically. The olympics basically encouraged rolls of the dice from riders that weren’t otherwise expecting to compete for a medal, because they had little to lose.