Not sure why people are so against the idea of electric bikes
I don’t think that people are against the idea of electric bikes per se, rather they’re against the blurring of conventional bikes into the realm of motorised transportation.
These bikes are being marketed not as an alternative to scooters or motorbikes running on roads and open byways but as an alternative to mountain, touring and hybrid bikes running in spaces which are traffic free.
Bikes are granted a fairly privileged level of access to rights of way in england and to the countryside as a whole in scotland – rights which are not extended to motorised vehicles, as such the blurring of one into the other is inevitably going to create tensions. Those who oppose the uptake of electric assist bikes see them as blurring the line and don’t think that either speed limiting or the necessity to pedal actually address a fundamental change to what it means to be a cyclist on the rights of way network.
That being said, I think that as an aid for those whose health and mobility compromise their ability to ride they’re a fantastic step forwards. As such I’m not really sure where I stand on them – with responsible use they could be a fantastic boon to cycling but they do jar with my perception of what should using cycle paths and bridleways.
Anyway, hope that gives more of a sense of people’s misgivings.