Viewing 39 posts - 1 through 39 (of 39 total)
  • How to increase metal on metal friction?
  • molgrips
    Free Member

    I’ve got this USE Alien post from ages ago. These things are very light, but the clamp is a bit of a bastard to use and for some reason on one of the two I own it’s decided it likes to slip and revert to a slightly nose-up position, which is annoying.

    So I’ve tried:

    – Roughly sanding the surfaces and fitting it clean
    – Carbon assembly paste, the gritty stuff
    – Threadlock on surfaces prior to assembly

    What else? Some kind of weak glue is probably next on my list. Maybe even a droplet of superglue.

    benji
    Free Member

    Pop it in a lathe and roll some knurls on it.

    davidtaylforth
    Free Member

    Shit seatpost; put it in the bin.

    molgrips
    Free Member

    Just for clarification, it’s not the tube part of the post, it’s the three-piece clamp. Looks like this:

    The front and back piece grip the top of that alien-head shaped part, and the middle bit grips the underneath. The mating surfaces are flat alu on alu. The angle of the post is what slips.

    Shit seatpost; put it in the bin.

    Will make riding my bike hard I think.

    tomd
    Free Member

    perchypanther
    Free Member

    Make the clamp out of the same material as trumpets.
    Maximum friction guaranteed.

    molgrips
    Free Member

    Oh.. I have gasket compound in the garage. Worth a try.

    davidtaylforth
    Free Member

    Will make riding my bike hard I think.

    😀

    buy a new one aswell, obvs. Or even something second hand. I’ll lend you the money if you’re short of funds.

    midlifecrisis
    Free Member

    If I see correctly, you tighten up a bolt / some bolts that pull the front and back bits together. These sit on top of the alien head whilst the bit in the middle sits underneath it.

    Does this mean that you need to have these tightened up as much as is needed to ensure adequate friction and thus hold it in place?

    If so, might it not be worth considering a layer of grease to allow the front and back bits to slide over the curve of the alien head as the assembly is tightened?

    molgrips
    Free Member

    buy a new one aswell, obvs. Or even something second hand. I’ll lend you the money if you’re short of funds.

    Still seeing a capital outlay in this plan, something I try to avoid.

    Does this mean that you need to have these tightened up as much as is needed to ensure adequate friction and thus hold it in place?

    Correct – I have tried greasing it too actually – but I think maybe I’d be better off greasing the saddle rails and using something sticky on the actual head.. hmm.

    Never used to be a problem if done up sufficiently, but somehow a degree of slip in the past has worn it somehow to the point where it has found a position it likes, which is slightly annoyingly nose up.

    davidtaylforth
    Free Member

    Still seeing a capital outlay in this plan, something I try to avoid.

    Life’s too short to ride shit seatposts, or something. Sell it on the forum to a classifieds only user, then buy something decent like a Thomson.

    molgrips
    Free Member

    Thanks for not answering the original question at all, David 🙂

    davidtaylforth
    Free Member

    😀 I aim to please!

    Ok; you could try scratching/etching the surfaces of it with a sharp object.

    Or superglue some sand onto the surfaces.

    thisisnotaspoon
    Free Member

    WD40?

    Not a joke, it does actually increase friction under load by allowing roughness of the surfaces to lock into each other.

    Dibbs
    Free Member

    I had to ride home 10 miles once when my Alien seatpost clamp failed.
    I learnt several things:-
    1. Alien seatpost clamps are pants.
    2. Your legs get really tired when you have to stand all the time.
    3. It’s surprising how much you use you legs against the nose of the saddle to move the bike around.

    molgrips
    Free Member

    Tinas – I can see that – something to increase initial engagement but without enough greasiness to work under pressure. May try it before the gasket idea.

    philjunior
    Free Member

    You’ve greased the clamp bolt threads and head and tightened it right up, I take it?

    There’s a fair variation in the recommended torques on seat clamps. I’ve got one that’s 7Nm (a tiny nip) and one that’s 13Nm (really quite tight).

    I would probably bin it and get something that’ll work for £20 max though.

    onandon
    Free Member

    Slap on some wet weetabix and allow to to dry. Everyone knows dried weetabix is the toughest and roughest compound known to man.

    adsh
    Free Member

    Upgrade to a Sumo. This achieves a greater angle when it slips.

    molgrips
    Free Member

    I would probably bin it

    You new here? 🙂

    lovewookie
    Full Member

    those alien seatpost heads were a pain to setup correctly. I used to carry a suitably sized rock with me just in case I needed to adjust it.

    If you get them tight enough not to slip, then to loosen you’d need to undo the bolts and then hit them with the suitably sized rock to get the clamp open.

    The Cyclops version was supposed to stop that from happening as it had a locking washer on the bolt. All that did though was slide up the bolt, so you still needed a rock to undo the clamp.

    philjunior
    Free Member

    I would probably bin it
    You new here?

    Nah, just sleep deprived. 🙂

    I probably wouldn’t really bin it yet, but when it continued to annoy me until I replaced it I would be annoyed at myself for not binning it earlier.

    molgrips
    Free Member

    I use a 4mm allen key to jemmy it loose to adjust it.

    Bianchi-Boy
    Free Member

    Cut a shim to pack with from coke can.

    BB

    jemima
    Free Member

    Sounds like a job for a few blobs of weld…

    dragon
    Free Member

    Another in the bin it camp. Why bother with a piece of sh*t like this, which could fail at anytime? You even admit it is worn out. Just spend £30 and get something safe that works.

    molgrips
    Free Member

    It won’t fail at any time – it’ll just slip slightly.

    HansRey
    Full Member

    could it be that the internal diameter of the clamp is out-of-spec? Measure the internal diameter at multiple points for both clamps. If there is variation, that may explain the slipping. Also, do the same for the saddle rails.

    thomthumb
    Free Member

    my USE sumo is similar. I was going to try bearing compound on it.

    maccruiskeen
    Full Member

    it’s not the tube part of the post, it’s the three-piece clamp

    I used to have one – it struck me that they were the were designed more with a view to ease of manufacture rather than ease of use.

    No need to bin it – despite how difficult they are to use -they’re surprisingly easy to sell. 🙂

    Northwind
    Full Member

    Tighten the bolts til they snap

    davidtaylforth
    Free Member

    It won’t fail at any time – it’ll just slip slightly.

    Slipping is failure…..
    Persevering with a shit seatpost is failure…..

    molgrips
    Free Member

    it struck me that they were the were designed more with a view to ease of manufacture rather than ease of use.

    They are designed to be light – which they do very well. Weigh less than 200g and mine’s had my fat arse on it for 9 years…

    The usability issues are the downside!

    I will replace it if I can fix the dropper I now have for the Patriot.

    philjunior
    Free Member

    Trib gel may help too, although it’s more of use for press fitted items where you’re gettting sliding between two surfaces on fitting, not sure if that applies in your case:

    http://www.tribtech.com/app.1.htm

    thecaptain
    Free Member

    Those alien clamps are so shit, I got suckered into buying a couple many years ago and the amount of grief they give me…I wonder why I haven’t put it in the bin years ago. At least one broke, so only one more to cope with. Every crash, or even a heavy landing, and it will slip. And be a bugger to readjust to the correct angle. Shit shit shit.

    Bez
    Full Member

    I had to ride home 10 miles once when my Alien seatpost clamp failed.

    You did well. I don’t think I even got 10 miles out of mine!

    molgrips
    Free Member

    Much as I like to stick up for things, the clamp is a bit shit in all respects apart from weight weenieness.

    The 3mm allen key in the cyclops version is in no way suitable for handling the required torque. I dremelled a slot in mine and use a big fat screwdriver. Which isn’t a practical part of my trail kit.

    However the post itself is pretty robust – unlike the original one I had in 2001 which was one of the first – that flexed like hell and eventually snapped – USE gave me a new one for free because they realised the earliest ones were under-designed.

    Bez
    Full Member

    Yeah, mine would have been an early one, same sort of time. I recall looking at the shaft after my clamp failed and thinking the two had simply had a race to see which could collapse first. I’m glad they revised things a little 🙂

    molgrips
    Free Member

    My first one was 25.4mm with a shim, come to think of it.

Viewing 39 posts - 1 through 39 (of 39 total)

The topic ‘How to increase metal on metal friction?’ is closed to new replies.