Had a 2003 1.4 auto seven speed paddle shift for 6 years from new, and did 50,000 miles. It was OK is all. Understeered like mad, engine rattled away until warm and the auto needed fluids changing every 3 years – one routine service cost us £700 with Honda. They never saw the car again. They leak where the roof joins the rear wing, easy fix but annoying. Got 41mpg out of ours. Paint thin. Never ever used the paddle shift.
The 1.2 manual is meant to be the better car.
Honda give you flowers when they service the car – may be a deal breaker for you 😀
The Fiesta was the much better car.