Guilty.

But foxxy

She’s hot.

Not sure I could date a convicted murderer though 🙁

until the appeal….

I’d expect her to live in the US for a long while yet. When people start going on about bad legal systems further afield the EU could probably do with having a look closer to home.

Guilty for now
Not sure how the high court will rule.

Danger sex?

Not sure I could date a convicted murderer though

Depends how’s desperate I was. I’m already partial to a danger w…….

Not much more risk surely.

Seems a right verdict to me. Chance of her spending time in an Italian jail is somewhat less than zero though.

Chances of her being extradited? Effectively nil (see Cavalese Cable Car Disaster)

Blimey, really?? 🙄

I’m not really up to date on it. I followed the original trial with interest, and I understand they’ve been reviewing the evidence or whatever…

So basically, she’s in America, the Italian courts have looked again at the evidence and decided that she actually is guilty, along with her friend Raphael. But unless the US forcefully send her back to Italy she’ll not serve her sentence? Is that the jist of it?

Could be talking bollox here (not followed the trial closely), but is the case against her not a bit flimsy to support a full monty murder charge? No convincing motive, previous good character, no physical evidence at all tying her to the murder (AFAIK?) plus the guy who actually did it is already locked up!
Her account seems bogus, but really you’d need some sort of irrefutable physical evidence to carry a guilty verdict ISTM.

I thought all you needed was a jury tivdecide you were guilty .

Nah – you need to get everyone on the internet to agree it as well – even if they haven’t heard all of the evidence. In fact, I heard they were going to do away with juries and just let the Daily Mail do a readers poll.

Danger sex?

I would, but I’d hide the kitchen knives just in case

Could be talking bollox here (not followed the trial closely), but is the case against her not a bit flimsy to support a full monty murder charge? No convincing motive, previous good character, no physical evidence at all tying her to the murder (AFAIK?) plus the guy who actually did it is already locked up!
Her account seems bogus, but really you’d need some sort of irrefutable physical evidence to carry a guilty verdict ISTM.

Also the guy who admitted to the murder got a reduced sentence for naming Knox and Sollecito as being involved.

Whilst the verdict is all the very well, the real news is her new hairstyle – its awful.

I would, but then crazy women are my style…

I’m guessing she won’t return to Italy. Would this verdict (if not overturned…again…in a higher court) limit her travelling within, say, the EU? (Just a question out of curiosity.)

DD: I imagine so – an European Arrest Warrant would most probably be used.

Arse! She promised she’d pop in to say hello. 🙁

Without wanting to sound whiny, I know at least a couple of people who use the forum regularly knew Meredith kircher so maybe try to keep it classy folks.

Noted, apologies

Well enough to know how to spell her name correctly? 😉

So will she be locked up in the US or waltzing around like the queen of sheeba?

So will she be locked up or waltzing around like the queen of sheeba?

Are they the only two options available to her?

No idea.

I love the tittle of this thread.

As for guilty or not I have no idea, either way I wouldn’t.

Edit: Had my fair share of unbalanced girl friends and really don’t need another person emailing me a picture of her crying to show me how upset she is. True story.

I would however be interested to see what happens if she is found guilty and the Italian court seeks extradition.

Very dodgy police work.

I feel for Meredith’s family. What a horrible rollercoaster with one of the (guilty of something but what part exactly ?) sat freely on chatshows etc.

Foxy? I wouldn’t. Shes got a ‘look’. Slightly low-IQ. Obviously she isnt but she isnt right.

Irony and lack of self awareness!

I thought all you needed was a jury to decide you were guilty

In many countries, as in Italy, it is decided by judges who are ultimately appointed by the state and there is a degree of puzzlement over the idea of having your guilt decided by your ( amateur ) peers.

As for the verdict, I am somewhat conflicted – you have Knox who comes across as a wrong’un on one side, and some sloppy police work on the other. Throw in the story of Rudy Guede and you have a complete mess.

I feel for Meredith’s family.

This! Not being able to have closure and it all being dragged through the media again must be absolutely soul destoying.

Genius the Washington senator Maria Cantwell going on about having serious questions about the Italian justice system, when her state has 8 people on death row.

I love the tittle of this thread.

It’s the Daily Wail headline.

Evidence, uncertain.
Dubious stories.
Who knows what happened.

I guess here it might have been thrown out on grounds of insufficient evidence.

But, it’s not here, it’s in Italy.

Anyway, she’ll stay in the states, they won’t extradite, she’ll be effectively free, but unable to travel to a number of countries.

Which is an interesting substory in its own right, ie why exactly would the US not allow extradition of citizens.

I guess here it might have been thrown out on grounds of insufficient evidence.

I’ve not seen the evidence, have you?

Edit: Had my fair share of unbalanced girl friends and really don’t need another person emailing me a picture of her crying to show me how upset she is. True story.

I had one of those once! Funniest picture ever… Wish I’d saved it.

So her ex, not much mention of him, is he now serving his 25 years?

is he now serving his 25 years?

on parole waiting during appeal process but has had to surrender passport.

I thought all you needed was a jury tivdecide you were guilty .

I don’t think there was a jury in this case, but if there was, why are they right and the previous jury that found her innocent wrong?