Am I missing something, but with more expensive VED and increased fuel consumption that just means you’re spending far more money?! Surely the comparison is to spend less on a petrol one which saves you money in the long run…maybe.
Of course you could buy the same age / mileage petrol and save on your capital outlay. The point I was trying to make was that modern diesels are not the bullet proof tractor engines they used to be, and they’re liable for some hefty repair bills if you have to replace a turbo, DPF, DMF, depending on the make any one of them could be close to a £1k.
A petrol will cost your more in MPG, but at 10k PA your not gonna be spending thousands extra on fuel vs a diesel, and there is far less to go wrong.
<Internet anecdote>
My smug boss at work was eulogising at how much he was saving running his diesel 3 series. He didn’t like it to much when I pointed out that the fuel savings were great as they can pay for the DMF to be replaced (£900). Car is less than 40,000, BMW weren’t interested in warranty.