I’ve been debating this recently. Up until the last few weeks, my Soul275 has been pretty much all I’ve ridden offroad on since January. I’ve been logging on Strava, for comparison rather than competition (I’m hundreds of riders away from KoM’s) .
I was expecting the Soul to be blindingly faster up and possibly along and the FS to rule on the down.
What’s actually happened is the FS has edged in most places, and on a couple of descents, the Soul nearly gave the fastest rides.
Totally unscientific as different days, none of this is competition condition riding and there’s a wheel size difference (26er FS).
I enjoy riding both differently. I’ve concluded it’s our old friend “the best bike is the one you’re riding *now*”…