Visually it is still absolutely stunning. There have rarely been as large scaled and creative sets before or certainly since. The costumes and colouring are also superb.
Atmospherically, it’s darker than Donnie’s dark place.
It was a probably a shame that they cut as much of the original story as they did (almost inevitable if you don’t want a LOTR type yawn-fest), but as a film I think it stills stands up in its own right. I came to it as a kid, prior to reading the book which isn’t usually my favourite way to do it – but I think that following a mild obsession with Twin Peaks in the early 90’s, seeing Agent Cooper running around in an energy force-field and killing Sting was all I needed to cement a love for the film.
I certainly wouldn’t let ‘nukes’ spoil a fantastical story line – in such a universe (space-bending blobs, genetic witches, longevity spice mining, giant guard-worms), I struggle to see how using high energy weapons could be enough to put you off. Pretend ‘nuke’ means something else if it really bothers you?
To me, it was a visual treat, that a masterful Lynch seemingly injected a lot of his energy into – and created something that went beyond the short crowd-pleasing ‘battlestar gallactica’ type fest that the Studio were probably hoping for. In pulling the reigns in, the overall impact of the movie was muddied. Possibly.
It’s not something I can watch yearly, but every 5 years or so I find it a treat on many levels.
Slightly rose tinted from my perspective? Also possible.
Great sci-fi on a photographic level if nothing else.