Most of the bike frames that I’ve looked up have some issues in reviews eg.
On One 456 harsh ride/stiff – I think most steel frames are stiffer than epople imagine them to be. The mantra verticaly compliant, latteraly stiff isn’t true, you can try to mazimise vertical compliance, but it always results in more latteral movement than just building stiff in the first place.
Blue pig and Genesis Alpitude poor build quality – you’re on a budget
Sanderson life/blitz expensive(but nice) etc. – as above, and add in cotic to that list.
After years of being a ‘steel is real’ evangelist I’ve bought a HX1 as I wanted soemthing light and stiff, my last few steel hardtails had gotten progressively softer and borderline floppy, and before that they’d been heavier and stiffer. There isn’t (IME) a magic steel bike that matches they hype.
The one thing I really like about steel is it’s hard as f***. Building the HX1 I’d forgotten how easy it is to cross thread bolts if not paying 100% attention or even just scratch aluminium frames with cables! So steel really suits the peaks, lakes etc where they’re likely to be dropped on rocks etc.
Much as there’s something really nice about a quality steel frame, there’s also a lot to be said for jumping on a good aluminium hardtail and being able to feel the chain snap tight as the freehub engages and the whole thing accelerates without a hint of flex. I’ve never found a steel frame that quite does it.
Now Ti on the other hand, I’d love a good stiff Ti hardtail thats as hard and tough as a steel frame, but weighs as little as aluminium. borrowed a Ti 456 which fitted that description, but costs.